Any R1b1a2a1a1b's out there?

[onegunn]

I'm in that haplogroup, looking for match's.

[rms2]

I'm in that haplogroup, looking for match's.

You're P312+, right?

What all have you been tested for?

[onegunn]

Hi rms2,
R-P312, is what it says. Y-DNA - Standard Y-STR Values 111 DYS results. Not sure what else, taken just about all the tests. Not sure what it all means, could use some help in that area.
Thanks for the reply,
Bill

[ArmandoR1b]

Hi rms2,
R-P312, is what it says. Y-DNA - Standard Y-STR Values 111 DYS results. Not sure what else, taken just about all the tests. Not sure what it all means, could use some help in that area.
Thanks for the reply,
Bill

I am P312. Did you or a genetic match get a Deep Clade test? The Deep Clade tests for SNPs which are also called subclades. I am L176.2+ SRY2627- as far as SNPs are concerned.

[rms2]

@onegunn

Look at the top of your Haplotree page. There should be a list there of all the SNPs you were tested for.

[onegunn]

I got the deep clade tests. I had the 111 marker test.

P312+ U152- U106- SRY2627- M65- M153- L21- L2- L193- L176.2- L165- 

Y-DNA  R1b1a2a1a1b  Shorthand  R-P312  mtDNA  J1c5a 

Thinking about getting the Family Finder and Factoids tests. I use FTDNA.

Bill

[chris1]

I got the deep clade tests. I had the 111 marker test.

P312+ U152- U106- SRY2627- M65- M153- L21- L2- L193- L176.2- L165- 

Y-DNA  R1b1a2a1a1b  Shorthand  R-P312  mtDNA  J1c5a 

Thinking about getting the Family Finder and Factoids tests. I use FTDNA.

Bill

Hi Bill. If you give your FTDNA kit number/YSearch ID people can advise better by looking at your haplotype.

Looks like you have not tested one of the 'big three' brother SNPs in R-P312 yet. That is DF27. The other two are L21 and U152 and you are negative for them.

[onegunn]

What does it all mean so far?

[Jdean]

What does it all mean so far?

Well you are definitely P312+ something, are there still SNP tests pending ?

[onegunn]

FTDNA 222038, no all my tests are complete. How can you look at my dna results?

[Jdean]

FTDNA 222038, no all my tests are complete. How can you look at my dna results?

As long as you are in a project that displays the results then it's not normally to hard to find.

You have tested L21 neg so you need to go down the P312* root, not my speciality but probably a test for DF27 is in order.

You seem to be in a quite tight cluster defined by

DYS19 = 13
DYS437 = 14
DYS568 = 12

[onegunn]

Thanks Jdean, what exactly does that mean? Is that a geographic cluster? A dna cluster? Sorry, I'm real new to this.
Bill

[onegunn]

Found my ysearch id BSTUQ

I figured out how to see the dna there also.

Bill

[rms2]

DF27 is the SNP that characterizes a major P312+ subclade that is spread all across continental Europe and into the British Isles. It's a big one. You should test for it.

[kevin.miller]

I'm in that haplogroup, looking for match's.

Hi:

I am DF19+, testing for L644 right now.

Kevin Miller

[onegunn]

Response to my email by FTDNA,
"You cannot order any more SNPs off of the Haplotree because R-P312 was determined to be your terminal SNP. You were already tested for everything downstream from P312 and tested negative for everything else downstream of it. P312 would be the only positive SNP you tested for."
I guess DF27 don't matter?
So what does that say, no point in testing DF27? Maybe it would be a DF27-.
"tested negative for everything else downstream" ??? What???
Any words of wisdom appreciated.
Bill

[df.reynolds]

Response to my email by FTDNA,
"You cannot order any more SNPs off of the Haplotree because R-P312 was determined to be your terminal SNP. You were already tested for everything downstream from P312 and tested negative for everything else downstream of it. P312 would be the only positive SNP you tested for."
I guess DF27 don't matter?
So what does that say, no point in testing DF27? Maybe it would be a DF27-.
"tested negative for everything else downstream" ??? What???
Any words of wisdom appreciated.
Bill

They are, to a certain extent, correct. R-P312 is your terminal SNP [on their horribly out-of-date near useless haplotree], with the net result that you are unable to order any any other SNPs off of their [incomplete, missing any SNPs added in the last three years] haplotree.

For a current picture of the R-P312 tree, see the ISOGG Hg R tree at:
http://www.isogg.org/tree/ISOGG_HapgrpR.html

To order DF27, go to your FTDNA home page. Click on the "Order an Upgrade" button in the upper-right corner of the page. Then click on "Order an Advanced Test". Type "DF27" into the Marker box, select "SNP" from the Test Type pulldown. Click "Add" on the line for DF27, then "NEXT" and proceed with checkout.

FTDNA is supposed to be updating their tree in conjunction with Geno 2.0, so hopefully we will see a revised tree from them relatively soon.

Regards,
david

[onegunn]

I went to the advanced test page and found quite a few tests I qualify for, including DF27, went all the way to charge my card $49 before I backed out.
I wonder wtf is going on?

[Webb]

Bill, if you haven't done it yet, please join "the P312 and subclades project" on FTDNA.  When you do you will most likely receive an email from one of the admins giving you some advice on where to proceed next.  You did the right thing by following the advice from the other members as far as looking into DF27.  R1b-M269 is the largest haplogroup in Western Europe.  That group then splits into two large groups.  One being U106 which is found in Britain, Scandanavia, and northern Germany.  It is generally associated with the Saxon invasions.  The other, larger, group is P312.  This group is huge.  It consists of L21, which is found in Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Spain, and France.  Ireland is around 90% L21.  U152 is another branch which is found in northern Italy heading west through eastern Spain and north through Britain.  The third group is Df27.  This group has the largest distribution of the three.  It is found from Britain, south to Spain, then east all the way to the Slavic countries including Poland.  It is as far north as southern Germany and as far south as northern Germany.  There are a few other smaller groups just downstream of P312 but they are a little more regionalized.  If you are L21- and U152-, then you should definitely test DF27.
Billy Webb

[Webb]

Sorry, I meant from southern Germany south to northern Italy in regards to DF27.

[onegunn]

Latest reply from FTDNA, "Our current Haplotree indicates you have no other SNPs to test because the Deep Clade does all the testing on our Haplotree. Of course, there are other newer SNPs that we offer as part of testing that are not currently on our tree. So, if you would like to order an individual SNP that you have not tested, it will not show on the Haplotree but you can still order it."
They should highlight our, as in OUR haplotree.
So they will do other tests and let me know the results but it won't change my FTDNA haplogroup until more snps are listed in ftdna's haplotree.
So I guess I'll go back and order the DF27???
Maybe I'll wait until after the new year......
Thanks for all your help, I hope all of you have a nice one.
Bill

[gtc]

Latest reply from FTDNA, "Our current Haplotree indicates you have no other SNPs to test because the Deep Clade does all the testing on our Haplotree. Of course, there are other newer SNPs that we offer as part of testing that are not currently on our tree. So, if you would like to order an individual SNP that you have not tested, it will not show on the Haplotree but you can still order it."
They should highlight our, as in OUR haplotree.
So they will do other tests and let me know the results but it won't change my FTDNA haplogroup until more snps are listed in ftdna's haplotree.
So I guess I'll go back and order the DF27???
Maybe I'll wait until after the new year......
Thanks for all your help, I hope all of you have a nice one.
Bill

The word "current" should not be used in conjunction with haplotree in FTDNA's case.

It remains to be seen what FTDNA ends up doing about its hopelessly out of date haplotree now that Geno 2.0 is here.